The Mould Show
The Mould Show
Breathing in mould spores causes anxiety, memory deficits and increases pain perception
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Sickness behaviour following mould exposure has finally been validated. It turns out that anxiety, memory deficits and pain thresholds are all switched on by BOTH toxic and non-toxic mould. The research shows that mould spores and mould cell wall fragments can adversely affect the brain and influence behaviour by challenging and activating the innate immune system. In this week's Livestream I'm going to be talking about these important findings and making them understandable for a lay audience.
REFERENCES:
Harding CF, Pytte CL, Page KG, Ryberg KJ, Normand E, Remigio GJ, DeStefano RA, Morris DB, Voronina J, Lopez A, Stalbow LA, Williams EP and Abreu O. Mold inhalation causes innate immune activation, neural, cognitive and emotional dysfunction. Brain, Behaviour, and Immunity. Available online 18th November 2019. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0889159119303010
Anand KS and Dhikav V. Hippocampus in health and disease: An overview. Ann Indian Acad Neurol. 2012 Oct-Dec; 15(4): 239–246. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3548359/
Boato, F., Hechler, D., Rosenberger, K. et al. Interleukin-1 beta and neurotrophin-3 synergistically promote neurite growth in vitro . J Neuroinflammation 8, 183 (2011) doi:10.1186/1742-2094-8-183
Cui J, Chen Y, Wang HY, Wang RF. Mechanisms and pathways of innate immune activation and regulation in health and cancer. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2014;10(11):3270–3285. doi:10.4161/21645515.2014.979640
Jones, CL. Environmental exposure patterns for airborne particulate matter (PM2.5 and PM10) inside residential properties. ACNEM Journal. 2016; 35(1): 20-21.
Hello and thanks for joining today on this live stream. I'm talking today about mould and this is going to be a really, really interesting Livestream. And why this is going to be fascinating is that we're talking about the relationship that these microorganisms that we can culture out on Petri plates and we can use various different types of environmental sampling techniques like tape lifts and optical particle counting and molecular probes and ATP tests. All of these are ways in which we can measure or quantify the microbial world. But one of the things that I am really, really excited to be talking about today is a summary of this particular paper which was just published, really 10 days ago in the literature. And we're going to be focusing on this quite significantly. And really the focus of this is some really groundbreaking research which has been appearing with various different authors in the literature over the last couple of years.
But this is coming out of America and this paper I consider probably one of the most important publications that have appeared certainly in the last couple of years. And I think it is just a fantastic publication because it validates what so many people who are concerned about the relationship between water damage and mould and mould exposure feel inside their bodies. And this particular paper is really going to focus on how mould has been in a sense inextricably linked and now proven to cause memory deficits, increase in anxiety, changes in the perception of pain and all sorts of impacts on the innate immune system. Basically we're going to be talking about all of this and more on today's live stream. But just remember, but this relates to environmental exposure to mould and in many cases, once we culture this out or use some other way of measuring this, we can make it visible.
But in many water-damaged building environments, it's just not visible. I'm going to change this now for you. In many cases, this is what we find in our homes. You'll get some unexpected water breach. And so people often complain about living and working in water-damaged buildings and they often after time, a short period of time start growing mould. And it's very common for these individuals to suffer from a range of adverse health symptoms. But in many cases, these range of health symptoms is not taken seriously by friends and family and often even members of the medical community.
To date, there are no published papers that have done controlled experiments where mould exposure has been linked to brain function until this particular publication. And this appeared as I said 10 days ago in Brain Behavior and Immunity. And I really need to make a shout out to Caleb Rudd, who is a very active member of the Australasian community who is focusing on mould because he really drawing my attention to the existence of this publication and certainly Cheryl Harding over at the City University of New York has been publishing in the last couple of years about immunity and how various different microorganisms can create a spike in the immune response in rodents.
So we're going to be focusing on this latest paper and basically the title of this paper is mould inhalation causes innate immune activation, neural cognitive and emotional dysfunction. And really this is just a fantastic publication because succinctly in this paper it draws on so many people's experiences and validates it in an animal model. As well it puts forward an entire model linking the immune system and the cognitive system with the motor responses that are seen in these rodents. We're going to be talking about this and unpacking this publication. As I said, it was published recently of came out as I pre-print on the 18th of November, 2019 there are a few tiny little typos in it and I will point these out in one of the graphs because we need to look at that now.
I would suggest that anyone who has got any type of mould exposure issue, who wants to explain to other persons that mould exposure and mould illnesses is very real, really needs to go to the source, pay for the publication or at least read the abstract review, the Livestream and what we're doing here and what is also going to be presented in the show notes underneath this live stream. Because I'm linking to some other academic articles that will make the whole experience of understanding this publication a little bit easier.
Now obviously I said that it was Cheryl Harding and coworkers. Every single one of these individuals is from the City University of New York. And they were asking a couple of key questions in their publication. And the first was would repeated known doses of mould spores cause an innate immune activation? And what they did is they looked at two types of mould spores and obviously we'll talk about this with its relationship to chronic inflammatory response syndrome to toxic mould and most well known and example being the Stachybotrys chartarum or the black mould. And then other people who really don't like to consider the ramifications of mould exposure, say, "Oh, well that particular mould that we found in your property, was a nontoxic variety of these are normal moulds that are, as I said, present out in the atmosphere."
As you can see, this is the outdoor control that someone sent through and their interested in the relationship to the indoor heating. But these are the types of things, we're surrounded by these moulds all the time. So that is normal. I'm not disputing that. But the issue is what does happen to your body? What is the underlying physiology? How is this affecting, your mood? We've talked about depression before on these live streams, but what about anxiety? What about the fact that many people who call me tell me that they are in pain or that their pain thresholds are altered? In this particular article, they were looking at whether or not the toxic mould, Stachybotrys or a nontoxic version of mould. And how they did that is they actually wash the spores with ethanol to get rid of the immune priming cell wall coats.
It's the same spores, but they are considered innate and they call these toxic and nontoxic. And then the second question was, when these are presented to the mice, is there an impact on cognition? The emotional response of the rodents? And are their behavioural systems. And of course, this all comes down to something called the innate immune system, which is responsible in our bodies for responding to pathogens. And it is the first response system before you get production of these inflammogens or these cytokines, which then allow the body to remember in a sense and then respond to the challenge at a later point and time. So that's what your immune system does. And that in its own right is a very complicated system. And really, I won't go into it any further here. But the bottom line is that this publication is touching on all of these areas and brings all of them into play with their experiment and the findings and the results and the conclusions and the ramifications of this.
This is the infamous black mould Stachybotrys chartarum. And again, as I said that they use these spores washed and unwashed. And in the graphs that I'm about to show you, they labelled them as either toxic or the non-toxic varieties. And of course, they also presented an innate material to the rodents, the mice in this situation, which just was saline. There was no presence of microbial matter, cellular matter or that sort of thing. And that is called VEH in the publication notes. So, what did they do? Well, they got a whole lot of mice, in fact, 122 mice and yes I should say at the outset that these mice were sacrificed at the end of the experiment. We all owe these mice a great deal of gratitude and thanks and especially to the scientists who really have put together a most elegant paper.
Really these mice have done a wonderful thing for humanity because from how they responded physiologically and behaviorally and all this beautiful paper has come into the public domain. I also need to touch on something called the hippocampus because the hippocampus is the structure or area in the brain which is responsible for learning. It also allows us and these mice to make goal-oriented behaviours and it allows them to move about in space. This is really at the entry of the spinal cord into the brain stem and it's quite closely connected to other important regions of the brain, which are responsible for, temperature and hunger and fatigue and all of that. This area of the hippocampus has been postulated as being inextricably impacted on by environmental threats. This is one of the core cognitive locations that the researchers were looking to find.
What they did with all of these experiments is apart from testing them out for learning and anxiety and controlled fear, eventually, they were sacrificed and they examined their brain. Basically they were able to look at the amount of neurons or what is called neurogenesis. That is the branching or the ability of the brain to actually develop because they got mice at two different ages to reflect very young mice and older mice. Now, before I get into the beautiful graphs, I want to paint you a word picture for what they did. So basically one of the first things that they looked at was allowing the mice to inhale different concentrations of these mould spores. And what they did is they got a microscope like I've got right next to me here. And something called a hemocytometer, which allows you to measure out known concentrations of spores.
Basically they made some different conditions that they then induce the mice to breathe this in. So the mice inhaled these mould spores. And again, they were 400 spores, 4,000 spores or 15,000 spores. So they had a gradient from no, to low, medium and high concentrations of mould spores. And then they looked at what happened to the mice when they were placed into a maze. And this maze essentially was a very much like a T-intersection that you would find on any road. But unlike a T-intersection, it had a one plank in a sense without walls and one where there were walls. This provides an environment or local environment which can either induce some amount of fear in the rodents and you can imagine that they might want to seek shelter behind the wall or if they're feeling particularly adventurous, they will spend more time out in the open.
So this is a classical maze experiment which is used in a lot of research that is looking at how the brain influences behaviour. And again, image analysis is used to track the time that the mouse spent in each of the different areas of the maze. And when they're looking at conditioned fear, this is what it actually looks like in reality. What they did is that, in order to work out whether the mouse is actually learning something, they played a sound, a repeatable sound for 15 seconds. And they also applied a very small shock to the foot of the mouse and they wanted to look at whether or not the mouse would either freeze. That is stand still in fear before moving away. And then by measuring the time that the mouse froze, when in future experiments, when they didn't shock the foot but they just played the sound that allowed them to work out whether or not the mouse is able to learn over time or actually remember things.
This issue is if it associates the sound with the foot shock, then how long will it take before the mouse moves away? And that essentially is how they establish this issue of condition fear. Now let's look at the data again. Remember in the top left-hand corner we've got the exposure of the Stachybotrys mould spores and now in... What they did is that again, I just want to recap on this. The mice breathe in either saline or they breath in toxic black mould or they breathe in a non-toxic black mould that had been washed with ethanol to not make it [inaudible 00:16:22] immune challenge. And if we look at the graph on the right-hand side, because the bottom legend on the left-hand one is a little bit skewed because this is a pre-print. But you can see that the NTX, which is the nontoxic mould spores impaired memory both at 30 minutes and 24 hours later.
And remember this is not shocking the mouse, this is just playing the sound to the mouse and you can see that there is significant differences in the ability of the mouse to actually remember the fact that the sound was connected with something that didn't feel very good. And this is an unbelievable piece of evidence because it shows that exposure to both toxic or nontoxic mould spores has the ability to impair this hippocampal memory. And really this is just a stunning result. Now again, looking down on this maze from a different dimension, I'd urge you to have a look at these mazes online. There are some great YouTube videos, but essentially it's a very simple experiment. They're just measuring how long the mouse spent in here and they can do a couple of different types of experiments using this maze and I'm going to move on to the next one now.
And they looked at now anxiety and I have lost count of the number of clients who have rung me really in a very anxious state because they are concerned about the water damage and mould in their property, but also they feel anxious and it's not just because it's unclean, it's they don't feel good and this whole concept of not feeling good and also having this connection between the exposure of the water damage not taken seriously by, as I said, friends and families and often medical practitioners and allied health care practitioners. This is a real issue and this publication demonstrates that there is a very real phenomenon hack happening here and it is very serious and again, what they wanted to look at with the maze again is how long the mice` stay in either open areas or the walled areas because the time it takes and again using image processing and analysis, they can work out a whole lot of things about the anxiety and so the non-toxic exposure when the mice breathed in the nontoxic mould spores, they entered the open arms much less often.
That's really, really important because that demonstrates their ability to cope with the stress of the more open environment. And they also travelled much less distance. So if they did go into the more challenging or stressful environments, I didn't spend much time there. And you can see that there are widely different relationships between the exposure to the two types of mould spores. And really this is a fascinating next example of the deleterious or adverse impact of the mould exposure on these mice and how they actually behave. So we've shown that it impacts on memory. We've shown now that it increases anxiety. And now the next type of experiment that the researchers looked at is what happens to pain. And no, they didn't hurt these mice very badly at all, but they shone a light on their tail and they measure the time it takes for the tail to actually move.
Again, it's a simple and elegant experiment to measure the time it takes for the mouse to move its tail because it's in some discomfort or pain. And let's look at the results here. And the latency is the time it took to flip the tail away and as you can see in the first bar graph that the exposure to the non-toxic and toxic mould spores meant that their perception of pain kicked in much earlier. And this is a really a big deal because it means that people who are saying, "I'm in pain today, that my environment is causing me discomfort." Well, you know, they're telling the truth because the mice response supports this.
Again, this is just beautiful, beautiful science here and a great example of a wonderfully done experiment. Now there's a lot in here. There's a very dense read. I certainly urge you to read this and share it with clinicians, but I want to talk about some of the conclusions that are in this particular publication as well because I did say that they were able to do a whole lot of other ancillary work as well as measuring cognition and anxiety and pain to see how they respond physically.
They did sacrifice the animals and they looked at a whole lot of other factors as well. The exposure to the toxic mould spores increased the level of something called interleukin one beta. And this is really an immune-modulating substance or material in the hippocampus, which is very, very strongly related to the priming of the innate immune system. Furthermore, when they sectioned the brains, they found that nontoxic mould spores decreased neurogenesis and essentially neurogenesis controls the growth and development of new neurons. So exposure to the mould decreases the ability of the brain to adapt and develop and form new connections within the brain. And of course in young mice, exposure to nontoxic mould spores decreased the memory ability in young mice. And it also decreased pain thresholds in older mice.
The take-home key points here is that mould spores increase anxiety behaviour. The innate immune system explains how the body responds to foreign substances invading microorganisms, and now both toxic and non-toxic mould. And the most interesting thing here is that the nontoxic mould components can also be considered as exactly that those types of fungi which are ubiquitous in nature, very commonplace and a not known to necessarily produce strong allergic responses. But think of all the breakdown fragments that occur. Think about even when leaves break down, they fragment into smaller fragments. And this breakdown phenomena is typical of what happens to most vegetative material in the world. It becomes smaller over time. And these breakdown fragments are certainly what we measure when we use optical particle counting during home inspections to measure something called PM2.5, PM10 which again are the indices used to quantify pollution in the air.
Most people think of that as pollution from vehicles and exhausts and industrialization, but it is very related to size and particulate matter 2.5, it's 2.5 microns. Remember that the spores are often two, three, four, 10 microns in diameter. And over time they get sheared and they break down. Similarly, water-damaged building elements like roofing insulation with all the wind currents that are occurring inside a typical roof void with a tiled roof, they generate break down fragments. And these breakdown fragments according to this publication are shown to be in a sense just as toxic as intact whole spores.
This issue of particulate matter and micron and sub-micron particle challenge to the immune system affecting not only the ability of the brain to learn and produce a reaction like anxiety and also feel pain. You can see that all of these different aspects of reactivity to the outside world are being impacted on by what we breathe and a couple of years ago in 2016 I reviewed at that point, I think about six or 700 properties for which areas of the home were most likely to demonstrate particle challenges and I'm going to be reviewing this paper in the next few weeks, but essentially there are alternative indices to measuring mould and we need to move away from a strict analysis of spore numbers to take into consideration the fact that the microbiome or the microbiome of the indoor living environment is full of a whole lot of other cellular debris and this cellular debris, whether it's toxic or nontoxic, appears to our physiology as producing an immune response.
And this is a really, really interesting way of looking at the world because it means that we are potentially being adversely impacted on by a whole range of materials, which may not really have a name in a sense, but may just have a size and a [inaudible 00:27:14]. and I will leave you on that and next week we're going to be talking further about the ramifications of this publication because I think that they will be very widespread. I think that the entire domain of the connection between behaviour and cognition is really being opened up by these types of publications and I can imagine that there is going to be a lot of linking by other scientists back and cross-referencing back to this publication because it really does establish a very firm foundation for why mould and water damage in a built environment needs to be taken extraordinarily seriously as the serious health threat it is. Thanks for tuning in and I'll see you next week. Bye for now.